Jake Tech Lab

Carbonite vs Arq Backup

Arq Backup comes out ahead of Carbonite on 5 of the 6 things that decide this, going by what each maker publishes. The one that matters for you may be one the leader loses.

Carbonite
Carbonite
6.1
Fair
1 of 6 rounds
vs
Arq BackupWinner
Arq Backup
7.1
Good
5 of 6 rounds

The verdict

Arq Backup takes it, 5–1 on rounds.

On the published figures, Arq Backup takes 5 of 6 rounds. Treat that as a starting point and check the current figures on both pages, because prices and plans move.

Choose Carbonite if…

  • • You want Carbonite's edge on how much cloud storage you get

Choose Arq Backup if…

  • • You want Arq Backup's edge on what it costs per year and how many computers it covers

Round by round

  1. Round 1What it costs per yearArq Backup wins
    Carbonite5/10

    $95.99/yr

    safe basic regular yearly ($76.79 first year promo)

    • $95.99/yr, against $69.99/yr

    Source: carbonite.com ↗

    Arq Backup8/10

    $69.99/yr

    arq premium, per year

    Source: arqbackup.com ↗

    Arq Backup wins this round on what the company itself publishes.

  2. Round 2How much cloud storage you getCarbonite wins
    Carbonite8/10

    Unlimited

    cloud backup storage

    Source: carbonite.com ↗

    Arq Backup5/10

    1 TB

    cloud storage included in arq premium

    • 1 TB, against Unlimited

    Source: arqbackup.com ↗

    Carbonite wins this round on what the company itself publishes.

  3. Round 3How many computers it coversArq Backup wins
    Carbonite5/10

    1 computer

    safe basic devices

    • 1 computer, against 5 computers

    Source: carbonite.com ↗

    Arq Backup8/10

    5 computers

    computers covered by arq premium

    Source: arqbackup.com ↗

    Arq Backup wins this round on what the company itself publishes.

  4. Round 4How long old versions are keptArq Backup wins
    Carbonite5/10

    30 days

    deleted files kept

    • 30 days, against Every version kept

    Source: support.carbonite.com ↗

    Arq Backup8/10

    Every version kept

    old version retention (default: keep all)

    Source: arqbackup.com ↗

    Arq Backup wins this round on what the company itself publishes.

  5. Round 5How long you can try it freeArq Backup wins
    Carbonite5/10

    15-day free trial

    free trial

    • 15-day free trial, against 30-day free trial

    Source: carbonite.com ↗

    Arq Backup8/10

    30-day free trial

    free trial

    Source: arqbackup.com ↗

    Arq Backup wins this round on what the company itself publishes.

  6. Round 6Whether it covers network drivesArq Backup wins
    Carbonite5/10

    No NAS backup

    nas only on safe backup pro

    • No NAS backup, against Backs up network shares

    Source: support.carbonite.com ↗

    Arq Backup8/10

    Backs up network shares

    backs up network shares

    Source: arqbackup.com ↗

    Arq Backup wins this round on what the company itself publishes.

CarboniteCarbonite
Arq BackupArq Backup

Side by side

CarboniteBest for how much cloud storage you getCarbonite
Overall score
6.1
7.1
Best
Price
See price
See price
What it costs per year
5.8
7.0
How much cloud storage you get
7.9
6.2
How many computers it covers
6.3
7.5
Which computers it runs on
6.2
6.3
How long you can try it free
5.7
7.6
Head-to-head findings
What it costs per year
$95.99/yr
$69.99/yr
How much cloud storage you get
Unlimited
1 TB
How many computers it covers
1 computer
5 computers
Which computers it runs on
Windows, Mac
Windows, Mac
How long you can try it free
15-day free trial
30-day free trial
Whether only you hold the key
Private encryption key
Private encryption key
How long old versions are kept
30 days
Every version kept
Whether it can image your whole drive
—
—
Record
Head-to-head record
0–7–1
5–1
Head-to-heads won
0 %
83 %
Rounds won
24 %
56 %
Pros
      Cons
      • $95.99/yr, against $49.99/yr
      • 15-day free trial, against 30-day free trial
      • No NAS backup, against Back up to network shares
      • $95.99/yr, against $39.95/yr
      • 1 TB, against 5 TB
      • 5 computers, against Multiple computers
      • Windows, Mac, against Windows, Mac, Linux
      • $69.99/yr, against $49.99/yr
      Add a third option to this comparison →

      More backup services match-ups